A few years ago I received some excellent training from Peacemaker Ministries in conducting mediations. A prayerfully conducted mediation session can be a great gift for hurting people.
The pattern which I was taught involves (1) A Bible study with some pointed application questions to prepare the participants for the time they’re going to have together (2) The parties involved setting aside a full day (if needed) for the mediation (3) The presentation of some ground-rules by the mediator (4) The sharing of opening statements, followed by a longer “story telling” time by the participants (5) Clarification of the issues involved, with much help from the mediator (6) A prayerful brainstorming process to evaluate various solutions (7) All participants committing themselves to positive actions or changes in their lives as they head for home. (Note how the Apostle Paul seems to be calling for some sort of mediation in Philippians 4:1-3.)
When the process hasn’t worked, it has only been because one or more parties to the mediation refused to do their homework, arrived at the session unprepared and subsequently refused to admit any part in the problem (I John 1:5-10).
Thankfully, this has been rare. Almost all of the mediation sessions I’ve led have resulted in at least some degree of reconciliation. Most regenerated believers in Christ, indwelt as they are by the wonderful Holy Spirit of God, are willing to at least begin to come clean regarding their sins, mistakes, missteps, poor communication or unfair expectations. Typically, these blessed sessions end well, with all involved thanking God for His help (II Corinthians 2:5-11).
Some situations, unfortunately, call for more of, what I’m going to call, a “shepherd’s intervention.” By this I mean a session in which a team of church leaders – the terms we use vary with our denominational “tribes” – speak carefully, graciously, lovingly, clearly and authoritatively into the life of a church member or members who are hurting themselves and others by way of their sinful, selfish behavior (Matthew 18:15-20).
In some cases their sinful behavior has hurt one or more other congregants; in other cases their sinful words have been leveled against one or more of their church’s leaders (I Thessalonians 5:12-15, Hebrews 13:7, 17).
Many of you will recognize the process I’m describing as one step in what we commonly call, “church discipline.” While the term isn’t found in the Bible, the practice certainly is, and it is decidedly not draconian, vindictive or punitive (when done well). It is simply a loving response to the self-destructive or destructive behavior of a beloved church member (II Timothy 2:14, 24-26, 3:16, 4:4, II Thessalonians 3:6-15, I Corinthians chapters 5 and 6 and II Corinthians chapter 2).
The secular world calls these gatherings “interventions,” and has learned how valuable they can be in helping alcoholics, drug addicts and others who are trapped in a sin (Galatians 6:1-5).
While it’s important that the church leaders in a shepherd’s intervention show themselves willing to listen patiently and carefully to the individual or individuals they are rebuking and exhorting, these conversations are not “peer on peer,” equals addressing equals (II Timothy 2:24-26). These conversations involve the leaders of the flock speaking seriously and authoritatively and communicating that they fully expect the individual or individuals being addressed to repent of their sinful behaviors.
On some occasions, a mediation session between a church member and a group of church leaders might be appropriate, such as when a church member is making accusations regarding the church’s leaders which an outside consultant, denominational leader, mediator or interventionist feels might have some validity.
On one occasion, for instance, I conducted a mediation between an entire church board and a pastor (and it ended well, thank God). I would do this again, in a heartbeat.
But a shepherd’s intervention is probably more appropriate than a mediation when:
(1) An individual or group of individuals in the church have engaged in behaviors which are clearly, incontrovertibly, obviously sinful and divisive (Acts 20:28-32). At times, as in the Acts passage just cited, the sinful or unethical or illegal behavior is the behavior of one or more of the leaders themselves. In such cases the intervention needs to be several leaders carefully confronting one or more “of their own number.” In such situations, help from an outside consultant or denominational leader is invaluable.
(2) An individual in the church has demonstrated a repeated, long-term pattern of harmful, behavior, such as gossip, bullying or manipulative behaviors. If these behaviors are common knowledge in the congregation, there is no need to subject the church’s leaders to the verbal abuse which is likely to be heaped upon them in a mediation session. There are people in our churches, blessedly few in number, fortunately, who would welcome the opportunity to attend a mediation session as one more venue for attacking those in authority.
(3) An individual in the church has consistently, over time, exhibited marks of a diagnosable mental illness or is known to have been diagnosed by a mental health professional with such an illness. Church leaders must love and care compassionately for the most troubled of the sheep; but some of these individuals are not candidates for a mediation process by virtue of their inability to think clearly or behave in a civil manner in a mediation setting.
(4) An outside interventionist (as above) studies the church’s situation and determines that it calls for a shepherd’s intervention, rather than a mediation. Where angry church members are leveling charges against their church’s leaders, especially in a public manner, it is important to get an outsider’s objective-as-possible evaluation of the situation, so that the church leaders themselves do not end up becoming guilty of bullying, controlling behaviors.
My prayer is that – even if you are a member of a church’s leadership team – you are able to file this post away and never use it.
If I have confused or irritated you in any way, or you’d just like someone to talk to and pray for you, or you could use some help in organizing a mediation or intervention, please feel free to contact me at churchwhisperer@gmail.com. Let’s set something up.

